Friday, March 27, 2015

Are Future Teachers Fooling Themselves?

The headline read: "College Students to Veteran Teachers: Quit Telling Us to Avoid Teaching." You will find the link to that story below. Here is my reply to the college students:

Good! This is exciting, and not unlike the idealism, energy, vision, and hopefulness of other generations of new (not necessarily young) teachers. These young adults are, however, preaching to the choir if they are aiming their resistance at working teachers. It is the mind and the vote of the general public they should be trying to influence. 
The hypocrisy of boards and policy makers and the disrespect they have for the profession are way out of control, driving public education toward a crash and burn. These political bodies' negativity toward our profession implants feelings of powerlessness among educators and stirs misunderstanding and apathy among the public. If you, future teachers, are not taking that seriously enough, you, too will crash and burn sooner than you think. 
Schools are workplaces. When the pedal hits the metal, teachers must navigate not only such regular nuisances as supplies distribution, equipment repair, and facilities maintenance, but they also must negotiate workplace politics and power games. They must maintain equilibrium amidst co-workers, including administrators, with varying degrees of competency levels. Sure, dedicated teachers of any age are most exhilarated by the actual teaching, the engagement with students, the witnessing of learning taking place! But these same teachers, no matter how hard they resist it, are worn down by bureaucracies and insensitive voters. 
Young employees in any field are quick to judge and dismiss older workers -- so what's new? Stick to your advocacy for students, but let no one convince you that it is less important than advocating for yourself, your colleagues, and your profession. You will be a 30-year-old one day. You must earn a living -- an adult's salary, a livable wage. Loving teaching is never enough. The profession requires you to step all the way inside it, not with theory but with full application. Your workday never ends. 
Will you want to sacrifice a fair and decent living at the same time? Teaching will try to pull a fast one on you, tell you that you are a special kind while compensating you with a minor fraction of what the textbook salesperson makes. That question is something you won't want to put far into the back of your mind.

"College Students to Veteran Teachers: Quit Telling Us to Avoid Teaching." 
http://news.yahoo.com/college-students-veteran-educators-quit-telling-us-avoid-224350002.html?bcmt=comments-postbox?bcmt=1427457427834-8906cfab-9985-4bd7-ae59-d633173fb779&bcmt_s=u#mediacommentsugc_container

2 comments:

  1. Teachers must advocate for themselves and new teachers would be well advised to fix the profession before they get into it. Long hours added duties and low wages are a proverb for K-12 educators. That is disrespect and needs to be fixed. Sadly once you are in the classroom it is next to impossible to find the time, support or energy to tackle those issues as they consume you. Teachers are the foot soldiers of education and they must command a seat in the planing meetings not just blindly wait for marching orders. Well said Advocacy Girl

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very well stated. Especially from one of the few excellent teachers/educators I've dealt with through my careers - as a former teacher and as a retired public librarian.

    ReplyDelete